Federated Learning for Text Generation

NOTE: This colab has been verified to work with the latest released version of the tensorflow_federated pip package, but the Tensorflow Federated project is still in pre-release development and may not work on master.

This tutorial builds on the concepts in the Federated Learning for Image Classification tutorial, and demonstrates several other useful approaches for federated learning.

In particular, we load a previously trained Keras model, and refine it using federated training on a (simulated) decentralized dataset. This is practically important for several reasons . The ability to use serialized models makes it easy to mix federated learning with other ML approaches. Further, this allows use of an increasing range of pre-trained models --- for example, training language models from scratch is rarely necessary, as numerous pre-trained models are now widely available (see, e.g., TF Hub). Instead, it makes more sense to start from a pre-trained model, and refine it using Federated Learning, adapting to the particular characteristics of the decentralized data for a particular application.

For this tutorial, we start with a RNN that generates ASCII characters, and refine it via federated learning. We also show how the final weights can be fed back to the original Keras model, allowing easy evaluation and text generation using standard tools.

pip install --quiet --upgrade tensorflow_federated

import collections
import functools
import os
import time

import numpy as np
import tensorflow as tf
import tensorflow_federated as tff

tf.compat.v1.enable_v2_behavior()

np.random.seed(0)

# Test the TFF is working:
tff.federated_computation(lambda: 'Hello, World!')()

b'Hello, World!'

Load a pre-trained model

We load a model that was pre-trained following the TensorFlow tutorial Text generation using a RNN with eager execution. However, rather than training on The Complete Works of Shakespeare, we pre-trained the model on the text from the Charles Dickens' A Tale of Two Cities and A Christmas Carol.

Other than expanding the vocabularly, we didn't modify the original tutorial, so this initial model isn't state-of-the-art, but it produces reasonable predictions and is sufficient for our tutorial purposes. The final model was saved with tf.keras.models.save_model(include_optimizer=False).

We will use federated learning to fine-tune this model for Shakespeare in this tutorial, using a federated version of the data provided by TFF.

Generate the vocab lookup tables

# A fixed vocabularly of ASCII chars that occur in the works of Shakespeare and Dickens:
vocab = list('dhlptx@DHLPTX $(,048cgkoswCGKOSW[_#\'/37;?bfjnrvzBFJNRVZ"&*.26:\naeimquyAEIMQUY]!%)-159\r')

# Creating a mapping from unique characters to indices
char2idx = {u:i for i, u in enumerate(vocab)}
idx2char = np.array(vocab)

Load the pre-trained model and generate some text

def load_model(batch_size):
  urls = {
      1: 'https://storage.googleapis.com/tff-models-public/dickens_rnn.batch1.kerasmodel',
      8: 'https://storage.googleapis.com/tff-models-public/dickens_rnn.batch8.kerasmodel'}
  assert batch_size in urls, 'batch_size must be in ' + str(urls.keys())
  url = urls[batch_size]
  local_file = tf.keras.utils.get_file(os.path.basename(url), origin=url)  
  return tf.keras.models.load_model(local_file, compile=False)

def generate_text(model, start_string):
  # From https://www.tensorflow.org/tutorials/sequences/text_generation
  num_generate = 200
  input_eval = [char2idx[s] for s in start_string]
  input_eval = tf.expand_dims(input_eval, 0)
  text_generated = []
  temperature = 1.0

  model.reset_states()
  for i in range(num_generate):
    predictions = model(input_eval)
    predictions = tf.squeeze(predictions, 0)
    predictions = predictions / temperature
    predicted_id = tf.random.categorical(
        predictions, num_samples=1)[-1, 0].numpy()
    input_eval = tf.expand_dims([predicted_id], 0)
    text_generated.append(idx2char[predicted_id])

  return (start_string + ''.join(text_generated))

# Text generation requires a batch_size=1 model.
keras_model_batch1 = load_model(batch_size=1)
print(generate_text(keras_model_batch1, 'What of TensorFlow Federated, you ask? '))

Downloading data from https://storage.googleapis.com/tff-models-public/dickens_rnn.batch1.kerasmodel
16195584/16193984 [==============================] - 0s 0us/step
16203776/16193984 [==============================] - 0s 0us/step
What of TensorFlow Federated, you ask? She
sat with soon it troubling place; it is true for our dear Charles to his wife, he affected marquis hand by all those creeturs to them, and
that they had seen the last dread of him, and all so mu

Load and Preprocess the Federated Shakespeare Data

The tff.simulation.datasets package provides a variety of datasets that are split into "clients", where each client corresponds to a dataset on a particular device that might participate in federated learning.

These datasets provide realistic non-IID data distributions that replicate in simulation the challenges of training on real decentralized data. Some of the pre-processing of this data was done using tools from the Leaf project (github).

train_data, test_data = tff.simulation.datasets.shakespeare.load_data()

The datasets provided by shakespeare.load_data() consist of a sequence of string Tensors, one for each line spoken by a particular character in a Shakespeare play. The client keys consist of the name of the play joined with the name of the character, so for example MUCH_ADO_ABOUT_NOTHING_OTHELLO corresponds to the lines for the character Othello in the play Much Ado About Nothing. Note that in a real federated learning scenario clients are never identified or tracked by ids, but for simulation it is useful to work with keyed datasets.

Here, for example, we can look at some data from King Lear:

# Here the play is "The Tragedy of King Lear" and the character is "King".
raw_example_dataset = train_data.create_tf_dataset_for_client(
    'THE_TRAGEDY_OF_KING_LEAR_KING')
# To allow for future extensions, each entry x
# is an OrderedDict with a single key 'snippets' which contains the text.
for x in raw_example_dataset.take(2):
  print(x['snippets'])

tf.Tensor(b'', shape=(), dtype=string)
tf.Tensor(b'What?', shape=(), dtype=string)

We now use tf.data.Dataset transformations to prepare this data for training the char RNN loaded above.

# Input pre-processing parameters
SEQ_LENGTH = 100
BATCH_SIZE = 8
BUFFER_SIZE = 10000  # For dataset shuffling

# Construct a lookup table to map string chars to indexes,
# using the vocab loaded above:
table = tf.lookup.StaticHashTable(
    tf.lookup.KeyValueTensorInitializer(
        keys=vocab, values=tf.constant(list(range(len(vocab))),
                                       dtype=tf.int64)),
    default_value=0)


def to_ids(x):
  s = tf.reshape(x['snippets'], shape=[1])
  chars = tf.strings.bytes_split(s).values
  ids = table.lookup(chars)
  return ids


def split_input_target(chunk):
  input_text = tf.map_fn(lambda x: x[:-1], chunk)
  target_text = tf.map_fn(lambda x: x[1:], chunk)
  return (input_text, target_text)


def preprocess(dataset):
  return (
      # Map ASCII chars to int64 indexes using the vocab
      dataset.map(to_ids)
      # Split into individual chars
      .unbatch()
      # Form example sequences of SEQ_LENGTH +1
      .batch(SEQ_LENGTH + 1, drop_remainder=True)
      # Shuffle and form minibatches
      .shuffle(BUFFER_SIZE).batch(BATCH_SIZE, drop_remainder=True)
      # And finally split into (input, target) tuples,
      # each of length SEQ_LENGTH.
      .map(split_input_target))

Note that in the formation of the original sequences and in the formation of batches above, we use drop_remainder=True for simplicity. This means that any characters (clients) that don't have at least (SEQ_LENGTH + 1) * BATCH_SIZE chars of text will have empty datasets. A typical approach to address this would be to pad the batches with a special token, and then mask the loss to not take the padding tokens into account.

This would complicate the example somewhat, so for this tutorial we only use full batches, as in the standard tutorial. However, in the federated setting this issue is more significant, because many users might have small datasets.

Now we can preprocess our raw_example_dataset, and check the types:

example_dataset = preprocess(raw_example_dataset)
print(example_dataset.element_spec)

(TensorSpec(shape=(8, 100), dtype=tf.int64, name=None), TensorSpec(shape=(8, 100), dtype=tf.int64, name=None))

Compile the model and test on the preprocessed data

We loaded an uncompiled keras model, but in order to run keras_model.evaluate, we need to compile it with a loss and metrics. We will also compile in an optimizer, which will be used as the on-device optimizer in Federated Learning.

The original tutorial didn't have char-level accuracy (the fraction of predictions where the highest probability was put on the correct next char). This is a useful metric, so we add it. However, we need to define a new metric class for this because our predictions have rank 3 (a vector of logits for each of the BATCH_SIZE * SEQ_LENGTH predictions), and SparseCategoricalAccuracy expects only rank 2 predictions.

class FlattenedCategoricalAccuracy(tf.keras.metrics.SparseCategoricalAccuracy):

  def __init__(self, name='accuracy', dtype=tf.float32):
    super().__init__(name, dtype=dtype)

  def update_state(self, y_true, y_pred, sample_weight=None):
    y_true = tf.reshape(y_true, [-1, 1])
    y_pred = tf.reshape(y_pred, [-1, len(vocab), 1])
    return super().update_state(y_true, y_pred, sample_weight)

Now we can compile a model, and evaluate it on our example_dataset.

BATCH_SIZE = 8  # The training and eval batch size for the rest of this tutorial.
keras_model = load_model(batch_size=BATCH_SIZE)
keras_model.compile(
    loss=tf.keras.losses.SparseCategoricalCrossentropy(from_logits=True),
    metrics=[FlattenedCategoricalAccuracy()])

# Confirm that loss is much lower on Shakespeare than on random data
loss, accuracy = keras_model.evaluate(example_dataset.take(5), verbose=0)
print(
    'Evaluating on an example Shakespeare character: {a:3f}'.format(a=accuracy))

# As a sanity check, we can construct some completely random data, where we expect
# the accuracy to be essentially random:
random_guessed_accuracy = 1.0 / len(vocab)
print('Expected accuracy for random guessing: {a:.3f}'.format(
    a=random_guessed_accuracy))
random_indexes = np.random.randint(
    low=0, high=len(vocab), size=1 * BATCH_SIZE * (SEQ_LENGTH + 1))
data = collections.OrderedDict(
    snippets=tf.constant(
        ''.join(np.array(vocab)[random_indexes]), shape=[1, 1]))
random_dataset = preprocess(tf.data.Dataset.from_tensor_slices(data))
loss, accuracy = keras_model.evaluate(random_dataset, steps=10, verbose=0)
print('Evaluating on completely random data: {a:.3f}'.format(a=accuracy))

Downloading data from https://storage.googleapis.com/tff-models-public/dickens_rnn.batch8.kerasmodel
16195584/16193984 [==============================] - 0s 0us/step
16203776/16193984 [==============================] - 0s 0us/step
Evaluating on an example Shakespeare character: 0.413500
Expected accuracy for random guessing: 0.012
Evaluating on completely random data: 0.007

Fine-tune the model with Federated Learning

TFF serializes all TensorFlow computations so they can potentially be run in a non-Python environment (even though at the moment, only a simulation runtime implemented in Python is available). Even though we are running in eager mode, (TF 2.0), currently TFF serializes TensorFlow computations by constructing the necessary ops inside the context of a "with tf.Graph.as_default()" statement. Thus, we need to provide a function that TFF can use to introduce our model into a graph it controls. We do this as follows:

# Clone the keras_model inside `create_tff_model()`, which TFF will
# call to produce a new copy of the model inside the graph that it will 
# serialize. Note: we want to construct all the necessary objects we'll need 
# _inside_ this method.
def create_tff_model():
  # TFF uses an `input_spec` so it knows the types and shapes
  # that your model expects.
  input_spec = example_dataset.element_spec
  keras_model_clone = tf.keras.models.clone_model(keras_model)
  return tff.learning.from_keras_model(
      keras_model_clone,
      input_spec=input_spec,
      loss=tf.keras.losses.SparseCategoricalCrossentropy(from_logits=True),
      metrics=[FlattenedCategoricalAccuracy()])

Now we are ready to construct a Federated Averaging iterative process, which we will use to improve the model (for details on the Federated Averaging algorithm, see the paper Communication-Efficient Learning of Deep Networks from Decentralized Data).

We use a compiled Keras model to perform standard (non-federated) evaluation after each round of federated training. This is useful for research purposes when doing simulated federated learning and there is a standard test dataset.

In a realistic production setting this same technique might be used to take models trained with federated learning and evaluate them on a centralized benchmark dataset for testing or quality assurance purposes.

# This command builds all the TensorFlow graphs and serializes them: 
fed_avg = tff.learning.build_federated_averaging_process(
    model_fn=create_tff_model,
    client_optimizer_fn=lambda: tf.keras.optimizers.SGD(lr=0.5))

Here is the simplest possible loop, where we run federated averaging for one round on a single client on a single batch:

state = fed_avg.initialize()
state, metrics = fed_avg.next(state, [example_dataset.take(5)])
print('loss={l:.3f}, accuracy={a:.3f}'.format(
    l=metrics.loss, a=metrics.accuracy))

loss=4.401, accuracy=0.140

Now let's write a slightly more interesting training and evaluation loop.

So that this simulation still runs relatively quickly, we train on the same three clients each round, only considering two minibatches for each.

def data(client, source=train_data):
  return preprocess(
      source.create_tf_dataset_for_client(client)).take(5)

clients = ['ALL_S_WELL_THAT_ENDS_WELL_CELIA',
           'MUCH_ADO_ABOUT_NOTHING_OTHELLO',
           'THE_TRAGEDY_OF_KING_LEAR_KING']

train_datasets = [data(client) for client in clients]

# We concatenate the test datasets for evaluation with Keras.
test_dataset = functools.reduce(
    lambda d1, d2: d1.concatenate(d2),
    [data(client, test_data) for client in clients])

The initial state of the model produced by fed_avg.initialize() is based on the random initializers for the Keras model, not the weights that were loaded, since clone_model() does not clone the weights. To start training from a pre-trained model, we set the model weights in the server state directly from the loaded model.

NUM_ROUNDS = 5

# The state of the FL server, containing the model and optimization state.
state = fed_avg.initialize()

state = tff.learning.state_with_new_model_weights(
    state,
    trainable_weights=[v.numpy() for v in keras_model.trainable_weights],
    non_trainable_weights=[
        v.numpy() for v in keras_model.non_trainable_weights
    ])


def keras_evaluate(state, round_num):
  # Take our global model weights and push them back into a Keras model to
  # use its standard `.evaluate()` method.
  keras_model = load_model(batch_size=BATCH_SIZE)
  keras_model.compile(
      loss=tf.keras.losses.SparseCategoricalCrossentropy(from_logits=True),
    metrics=[FlattenedCategoricalAccuracy()])
  tff.learning.assign_weights_to_keras_model(keras_model, state.model)
  loss, accuracy = keras_model.evaluate(example_dataset, steps=2, verbose=0)
  print('\tEval: loss={l:.3f}, accuracy={a:.3f}'.format(l=loss, a=accuracy))

for round_num in range(NUM_ROUNDS):
  print('Round {r}'.format(r=round_num))
  keras_evaluate(state, round_num)
  state, metrics = fed_avg.next(state, train_datasets)
  print('\tTrain: loss={l:.3f}, accuracy={a:.3f}'.format(
      l=metrics.loss, a=metrics.accuracy))

keras_evaluate(state, NUM_ROUNDS + 1)

Round 0
    Eval: loss=3.431, accuracy=0.389
    Train: loss=4.323, accuracy=0.091
Round 1
    Eval: loss=4.277, accuracy=0.149
    Train: loss=4.169, accuracy=0.189
Round 2
    Eval: loss=4.171, accuracy=0.174
    Train: loss=4.064, accuracy=0.194
Round 3
    Eval: loss=4.027, accuracy=0.184
    Train: loss=3.944, accuracy=0.196
Round 4
    Eval: loss=3.922, accuracy=0.202
    Train: loss=3.850, accuracy=0.198
    Eval: loss=3.836, accuracy=0.162

With the default changes, we haven't done enough training to make a big difference, but if you train longer on more Shakespeare data, you should see a difference in the style of the text generated with the updated model:

# Set our newly trained weights back in the originally created model.
keras_model_batch1.set_weights([v.numpy() for v in keras_model.weights])
# Text generation requires batch_size=1
print(generate_text(keras_model_batch1, 'What of TensorFlow Federated, you ask? '))

What of TensorFlow Federated, you ask? Says
for it on you. The Doctor, distinct, without which suddenly
behand, and experiated on his ear. "Shall I
do there are fatherals, and for I want do again
at the turnkeyshe had been glowed, tith

Suggested extensions

This tutorial is just the first step! Here are some ideas for how you might try extending this notebook:

Write a more realistic training loop where you sample clients to train on randomly.
Use ".repeat(NUM_EPOCHS)" on the client datasets to try multiple epochs of local training (e.g., as in McMahan et. al.). See also Federated Learning for Image Classification which does this.
Change the compile() command to experiment with using different optimization algorithms on the client.
Try the server_optimizer argument to build_federated_averaging_process to try different algorithms for applying the model updates on the server.
Try the client_weight_fn argument to to build_federated_averaging_process to try different weightings of the clients. The default weights client updates by the number of examples on the client, but you can do e.g. client_weight_fn=lambda _: tf.constant(1.0).